Wednesday, October 25, 2006

What makes me a woman?

Before my surgery someone told me to reconsider, because having hysterectomy would mean I would lose the essence of what made me a woman… That made me laugh at first, and then it made me angry. I tihnk I’m more than a pair of ovaries and a uterus! It also made me think, what makes a woman a woman?

A few days ago I saw news report on local TV where they were debating if brain had a sex. Some of the “experts” would say yes and others no. I’ve been thinking about this for the last few days… Is it our brain? Our organs? What? I don’t know.

I know that some women really identify through their bodies. I understand the issues of women with breast cancer who lose a breast and how much it can affect them. Our society is putting so much emphasis on looks, on big breasts, on how we should look, that it’s only normal to feel like they’ve been disfigured. But is a woman a woman because she has breasts?

While in the hospital one of my bed mates, who also had hysterectomy (after 3 kids), asked about my surgery and if I had any kid. When I told her no, she started to cry and to tell me how sad it was, etc. I just sat there looking at her as if she was as crazy as Bernice across the hall (a very delusional lady, across from our room). When she said “you poor thing”, it pissed me off. It really did. WTF? Before feeling sorry for me, did you ever think that maybe I didn’t want kids? She was so surprised. My ability to have kids did not make me the woman I am, or did it? I don’t know, and honestly I don’t really care! It was not something I wanted and now I know it won't happen, for sure. Anyway, I firmly believe that it's not because you can that you should!

If “losing” my uterus and ovaries took my womanly essence, then what am I now? I’m not a man either, so what am I? Do women going through menopause wonder if they are still women because their bodies stop producing those darn hormones? I wonder?

This series of questions brought on a whole other series, what about the transsexuals? They take hormones, have surgeries, etc. but despite all that, we never really consider them anything else other than what they were born as. I remember seeing this 10 years old on Oprah who was born a girl but always felt he was a boy and always acted as such. He had tried to commit suicide at age 5 because his parents wouldn’t let him be a boy. Following that attempt his parents “accepted” him as a boy trapped in a girl’s body. How weird is that, and yet I believe it can happen - nature do foul things up at times!

So, I’m asking you, what do YOU think makes a woman a woman? Am I a woman because I grew boobs, and then had periods? Or is it because I “look” like a woman with the hips, etc? Is it environmental? Is it because I was dressed like a girl and given dolls and told I was a girl? Is it the fact that I could give birth? What?

Any ideas?

12 comments:

PreppyGirl said...

I'd have to say, the techinical reasoning would probably be the amount of female hormones that have been in your body most of your life. That's what's given you your feminie features, etc. The way we act probably has a lot to do with conditioning and environment. As you know, there is probably no cut & dry answer. I like being a girl though!

Trueself said...

Oh gosh, I'm probably going to give an answer that will be rather controversial. I believe your soul determines what gender you are. It is a feeling, a way of thinking, an essence that transcends physical characteristics or hormones. It is an integral part of a person's psyche. The presence or absence of certain physical features have no bearing on someone's gender although most often it is the physical features upon which we depend to determine gender. So I believe that a boy could be "trapped" in a girl's body and vice versa.

Anonymous said...

Hm, that one is a toughie. I agree with the others, there's no easy answer to what makes us who we are. I definitely know that my uterus and ovaries are NOT the only thing that makes me a woman. I'm going to be 41 in just over a month and have never had children. I might have a tinge of regret about that but it doesn't make me any less of a woman for not having them. Like you said, maybe you just didn't want any. Not every woman is cut out to be a parent anyway. But if I had to put my finger on what makes me feminine, I'd have to say a kick-ass pair of heels. Man, I feel like a woman!!! ;-)

Purple Pigeon said...

Oh god, i hate that type of person that thinks that just cuz ur a woman, you want kids. I F**KING HATE them! And it really irritates me when people go ''ooooh wait til ur thirty, you'll change your mind''. I bleeding well wont! Who the hell are they to think they know me better than i know me?

Thanks Stinkypaw, for being another woman not afraid to say ''No, i didnt want them!''

On the gender thing, when i was doing Psychology for A level, we did a whole term about gender, and whether it comes from within, or if it is how you are treated, or a mixture of both. Personally, i think that in recent years, genders have been blurred, men are becoming very feminine (using more beauty products than women!!), females are becoming very masculine (in attitude, if not looks...tho i know some very manly women!) so it has got to a point that its how you feel, not about what equipment you have. On the other hand, i dont think that people should feel that they have to act feminine if they are a female, and masculine if they are male. Some men are just smushy creatures inside (in a good way), but have to act masculine to fit in. But who is to say what is acceptable masculinity and femininity anyway? You act how you feel you want to act. Hmmm, have been very serious for a while, i think i may have to have a lie down...

on another note, i think the person that said you would lose the essence of what made you a woman is a complete tosser. Didnt they think that you had enough to worry about with the thought of impending surgury without sapping your self esteem and confidence about your femininity? Idiot. Such people should be locked in a room with thier narrow mindedness and thoughtlessness til they choke on it (oooh getting a bit harsh there, i apologise!!)

Blimey, that was an essay of a comment!

mollymcmo said...

i agree in that this is a tough one, i think really its a combination of everyones answers (how that for being original?! LOL!)
hormones, your soul, your essence and even life experiences make you what you are
having a uterus or a penis isn't the bottom line of what makes us who we are.
i do like being a girl though and don't find the fact that i've had children my "female momement", i'm much more complicated than that ;)

m

stinkypaw said...

pg: Don't get me wrong, I do too!

c_t_w: Thanks! I don't know many gils who actually "enjoy" the bleeding thing!

trueself: Interesting answer, hadn't think of the soul as such...

I do believe also in the being trapped in the wrong body aspect too. Like I wrote in the post, nature can foul things up as well!

ananke: Love your answer! "kick-ass pair of heels" - Love it!

elf: Writing your dissertation has inspired you or something! Cool!
I don't get some of the "changes" happening in society nowdays. I want a man that looks and feels like a man, and at times I almost feel like that is wrong or something... weird!

I've never appologize for not wanting kids, and I will most likely never will either. It was somehting I thought about and it wasn't for me, so "losing" the ability to get pregnant doesn't bother me that much, it's that pain that came with it that I do mind!!

BTW, love you accent (even in writing) - Blimey! Love it! ;-)

m: You just had to write penis didn't you? Couldn't resist the urge, huh?!

I never thought that giving birth made a woman a woman and even less made her a "mother", it only made her a woman who has given birth!

Imagine, they removed parts that I've never used! I should get a refund or something!

cinnamon girl said...

Theoretically, it's your chromosomes that make you a women. But really, I think gender is a cultural and psychological construct.

I hate it when people boil it down to whether you produce babies or not.

Purple Pigeon said...

ha! Brilliant! I didnt know i had a typing accent! I'll keep it up

Crikey!

stinkypaw said...

hasarder: I know about the theory part the Ys and Xs, but I think there's more to it than that, and also it is so much more than baby production! ;-)

dan'd boone: I think that our souls are gendre free. Why do I think that? Because you don't always come back as the same sex (if you believe in reincarnation that is).

A lot of how we perceive ourselves come from our environment, our peers. We choose to follow or not the pre-established roles, like who should bring home the beacon.

I've been "agressive" all my life and yet, I do feel the need to be taken care of, etc. One doesn't exclude the other. There's time when I want my husband to "defend" me and other times when I could whip his ass! I've been told so many times that I'm not the "typical" girl for a bunch of little things, and I'm wondering if these were the things that made me a woman...

You're very welcome if you enjoyed the post - don't be shy to write stuff like that (like that post to your wife - nice!), on your blog you post what YOU want!

Kala said...

The way her hair smells, the feeling of her soft skin next to mines, the way she expresses herself in 2000 words what I would say in 2 words, the way she is able to debate and win every single debate we have, just the way she makes me feel without having to say a word, her soft gentle touch when it matters most, the way she looks into my eyes and somehow my credit card magically appears in her hands =D

Kala said...

btw, how are you feeling? From the operation and the reason for the operation - is the pains gone?

stinkypaw said...

kala: Now that's what you call a REAL woman! ;-)

I'm doing better everyday, thanks for asking!